BLM Says Dead Foal was Not Shot

Source

Holes in the carcass of a young foal found near a wild horse roundup in northeast California and Nevada were the work of scavenger birds not gunshot wounds as horse protection advocates first claimed, federal officials said Tuesday.

A veterinarian with the U.S. Agriculture Department's Animal Plant Health Inspection Service examined the foal on Saturday, two days after horse advocates opposed to the roundup found the animal and complained to the U.S. Bureau of Land Management.

The vet was unable to determine a cause of death because the foal had been dead for about a month and the carcass was already in the advanced stages of decomposition, BLM spokeswoman Jan Bedrosian said.

But "the bony skeletal remains of the four- to six-week old colt showed no detectable physical trauma," Bedrosian said in a statement on Monday. "There were random holes of various sizes that were evidence of feeding by scavenger birds, according to the veterinarian."

In addition, a BLM special agent examined the area and found no physical evidence around the carcass to indicate it was shot or killed at that location, Bedrosian said.

Craig Downer, a wildlife ecologist doing work with the Colorado-based Cloud Foundation, was with the group that found the foal last week. He said it was within a few miles of a corral where a BLM contractor with helicopters gathered hundreds of mustangs last week along the California-Nevada border.

Downer said BLM officers in the field initially dismissed the report, at one point telling one ecologist the carcass was that of an antelope, not a horse.

But he said BLM officials from the district office subsequently showed genuine interest in the case. He said they requested—and he provided—copies of photographs he took at the scene and BLM officials confirmed late Thursday they were investigating.

Downer, who has done numerous studies at the roundup site, said on Tuesday that he had not heard from BLM about the examination results. He said he thought that the USDA and BLM would have the expertise to determine the source of the wounds but that he remained suspect of the conclusion.

"What gets me is the near-perfect roundness of the hole going in," he told The Associated Press on Tuesday. He said he wants to see details of BLM's findings.

"I've seen how the high-powered rifle perforates and leaves the round hole going in and going out the other side ... Based on that fact alone, I would be a bit suspect of the conclusion."

Last week, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals refused a request by In Defense of Animals and others to block BLM's plans to roundup about 2,000 wild horses and 200 burros from the Twin Peaks Herd Management Area covering 800,000 acres along the state line.

Critics argued the horses have more of a legal right to the land than do thousands of livestock grazing there, but the court upheld the agency's action based on its conclusion the mustang herds are badly overpopulated and causing significant ecological damage.

Nancy Haug, BLM district manager for Northern California, said Tuesday that nearly 600 horses have been gathered to date in the operation expected to continue into September. She said there have been no injuries to personnel and no serious injuries to horses.

She said 32 horses previously gathered were returned on Tuesday to the Twin Peaks HMA, where BLM plans to eventually leave about 450 horses and 72 burros.